
Rabbi David Levin
This week’s Torah portion is Noach: Genesis 6:9 — 11:32
Somewhere around year 60, Noah must have asked himself a question. He is standing beside a half-built boat, nowhere near the sea. The neighbors have stopped ridiculing and laughing and have likely begun to pity him. And the question comes: What am I doing?
The Torah never specifies how long it took to build the ark. Rashi, drawing on the Talmud, says the people watched him at work for 120 years. Others estimate it took 75 to 100 years. Even in a world where people lived for centuries, that is a long time to wonder whether you’ve lost your mind.
But Noah had something most of us don’t: a Divine command. “Noah did so; just as God commanded him.” We likely have only an internal voice, with no way to tell whether it is a calling or mere wishing. And even Noah, the rabbis note, was not serene. Rashi, drawing on Bereshit Rabbah, says Noah both believed and doubted, questioning whether the flood would come, and entered the ark only when the water forced him. In other words, even with God’s instructions, he hedged.
Ideas are only ideas until we begin to carry them out, and that work is hard and rarely brings quick rewards. We love the stories of those who kept going. Jeff Bezos started Amazon in a rented house in Bellevue, Washington, using desks he built from doors. Jamie Siminoff pitched his video doorbell, then called Doorbot, to the Sharks (successful businesspeople who are investors) on the television show “Shark Tank” and walked away without a deal. He kept building, and Amazon bought Ring in 2018 for a reported $1.15 billion.
But those are the stories that get told. For every Siminoff, there are hundreds who heard the same internal voice, held on just as stubbornly and never made it to “Shark Tank,” let alone a payday. Perseverance is the one thing winners and losers share.
The real question isn’t whether to persevere. It’s how to know what you’re persevering for.
Some of us had an idea and let fear talk us out of it, the fear of failing and, for some, if we’re honest, the fear of succeeding. Some of us tried, found the work harder than we’d imagined and quit. Some of us planned and persisted until something real emerged. At the start, all three felt the same way.
This leaves me with a few questions: Where does this voice come from? Is it merely a fleeting idea, or a fundamental value or vision that keeps returning even if you try to dismiss it? Can you stand up to the critics, who will always be quick to tell you that you’re wasting your time? And when doubt arises, as it surely will, is it valuable and insightful, or simply fear?
There is one more test to borrow from Noah. His ark wasn’t merely a startup. It was also a shelter. A dream with room for his family, one that might someday carry them through a storm, is easier to trust when neighbors laugh. It is also easier to let go honestly if it turns out to serve only our vanity. Such motivation is part of the strength of ideas.
“Evan Almighty,” the movie starring Steve Carell as a congressman God tells to build an ark, plays it for laughs. He hesitates, is ridiculed and then builds anyway. Ultimately, he is proved right. Real life offers no such guarantee. Over the course of our lives, each of us faces tests like this more than once, and each time we must pause, examine the voice and decide honestly.
No one can answer for us.
May we have both the ability to tell the difference and the courage to act on it.
Hazak v’umatz. Strength and courage.
Rabbi David Levin is president of the Board of Rabbis of Greater Philadelphia and founder of Jewish Relationships Initiative.
